Shelter Island NY Hotels

Search among 27 available hotels and places to stay in Shelter Island from 50+ providers

Check-in
Sat, 19 Oct
-
Check-out
Sun, 20 Oct
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Check-in
Sat, 19 Oct
-
Check-out
Sun, 20 Oct
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
Check-in
Sat, 19 Oct
-
Check-out
Sun, 20 Oct
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
View map
Hotels
Holiday rentals
All types
1-27 out of 27
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island Exterior photo
The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island
Hotel
8.6
Great43 reviews
Map
3.1 km from City Centre
FromINR 28 041 /nightSelect
Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island Exterior photo
Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island
Hotel
7.8
Very good26 reviews
Map
2.3 km from City Centre
FromINR 50 038 /nightSelect
Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island Exterior photo
Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island
Bed & Breakfast
8.6
Great8 reviews
Map
1.9 km from City Centre
FromINR 69 096 /nightSelect
Rams Head Inn Shelter Island Exterior photo
Rams Head Inn
Hotel
8.4
Great10 reviews
Map
3.8 km from City Centre
FromINR 34 170 /nightSelect
Places to stay near Shelter Island
The Blue Inn At North Fork East Marion Exterior photo
The Blue Inn At North Fork
Inn
7.4
Very good9 reviews
Map
6.2 km from Shelter Island6.2 km from City Centre
FromINR 15 616 /nightSelect
A Walk In The Woods Bed And Breakfast Southold Exterior photo
A Walk In The Woods Bed And Breakfast
Bed & Breakfast
8.4
Great29 reviews
Map
5.9 km from Shelter Island5.9 km from City Centre
FromINR 34 002 /nightSelect
Greenporter Hotel Exterior photo
Greenporter Hotel
Hotel
8.4
Great40 reviews
Map
4.3 km from Shelter Island4.3 km from City Centre
FromINR 8 731 /nightSelect
The Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport Exterior photo
The Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport
Bed & Breakfast
8.6
Great32 reviews
Map
4.4 km from Shelter Island4.4 km from City Centre
FromINR 21 157 /nightSelect
The Chequit Hotel Shelter Island Heights Exterior photo
The Chequit
Inn
8.6
Great28 reviews
Map
2.2 km from Shelter Island2.2 km from City Centre
FromINR 56 083 /nightSelect
Shorecrest Bed And Breakfast Southold Exterior photo
Shorecrest Bed And Breakfast
Bed & Breakfast
7.8
Very good7 reviews
Map
6.5 km from Shelter Island6.5 km from City Centre
FromINR 27 286 /nightSelect
Baron'S Cove Hotel Sag Harbor Exterior photo
Baron'S Cove
Hotel
8.4
Great59 reviews
Map
8.2 km from Shelter Island8.2 km from City Centre
FromINR 18 386 /nightSelect
Arbor View House Bed And Breakfast East Marion Exterior photo
Arbor View House Bed And Breakfast
Bed & Breakfast
8.6
Great34 reviews
Map
6.5 km from Shelter Island6.5 km from City Centre
FromINR 34 086 /nightSelect
Fordham House Hotel Greenport Exterior photo
Fordham House
Hotel
Map
5.1 km from Shelter Island5.1 km from City Centre
Select
The Harbor Front Inn Greenport Exterior photo
The Harbor Front Inn
Hotel
8.4
Great51 reviews
Map
4.2 km from Shelter Island4.2 km from City Centre
FromINR 18 806 /nightSelect
American Beech Hotel Greenport Exterior photo
American Beech Hotel
Hotel
8.4
Great54 reviews
Map
4.4 km from Shelter Island4.4 km from City Centre
FromINR 17 127 /nightSelect
Historic White Blossom House Hotel Southold Exterior photo
Historic White Blossom House
Inn
7.4
Very good3 reviews
Map
8.0 km from Shelter Island8.0 km from City Centre
FromINR 37 780 /nightSelect
Sound View Greenport Hotel Exterior photo
Sound View Greenport
Hotel
8.4
Great62 reviews
Map
5.7 km from Shelter Island5.7 km from City Centre
FromINR 28 629 /nightSelect
The Menhaden Hotel Greenport Exterior photo
The Menhaden Hotel
Hotel
8.0
Great24 reviews
Map
4.2 km from Shelter Island4.2 km from City Centre
FromINR 29 301 /nightSelect
Shelter Island House Hotel Shelter Island Heights Exterior photo
Shelter Island House
Hotel
8.6
Great20 reviews
Map
1.9 km from Shelter Island1.9 km from City Centre
FromINR 23 592 /nightSelect
House On Chase Creek Bed & Breakfast Shelter Island Heights Exterior photo
House On Chase Creek
Bed & Breakfast
8.4
Great16 reviews
Map
1.9 km from Shelter Island1.9 km from City Centre
FromINR 19 394 /nightSelect
The Shoals Suites & Slips Southold Exterior photo
The Shoals Suites & Slips
Hotel
8.4
Great12 reviews
Map
5.5 km from Shelter Island5.5 km from City Centre
FromINR 16 707 /nightSelect
Harbor Knoll Bed And Breakfast Greenport Exterior photo
Harbor Knoll Bed And Breakfast
Bed & Breakfast
8.6
Great16 reviews
Map
4.0 km from Shelter Island4.0 km from City Centre
FromINR 28 377 /nightSelect
Zey Hotel Greenport Exterior photo
Zey Hotel
Bed & Breakfast
8.0
Great26 reviews
Map
4.4 km from Shelter Island4.4 km from City Centre
FromINR 25 103 /nightSelect
Hotel Moraine Greenport Exterior photo
Hotel Moraine
Hotel
9.6
Perfect4 reviews
Map
5.6 km from Shelter Island5.6 km from City Centre
FromINR 55 411 /nightSelect
Harbor Knoll Bed & Breakfast Hotel Greenport Exterior photo
Harbor Knoll Bed & Breakfast
Hotel
8.0
Great2 reviews
Map
4.0 km from Shelter Island4.0 km from City Centre
Select
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows Greenport Exterior photo
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Hotel
8.4
Great6 reviews
Map
4.3 km from Shelter Island4.3 km from City Centre
FromINR 44 077 /nightSelect
Sag Harbor Inn Exterior photo
Sag Harbor Inn
Hotel
8.2
Great12 reviews
Map
8.1 km from Shelter Island8.1 km from City Centre
FromINR 28 041 /nightSelect

Shelter Island hotels essential information

🏨 Hotels in Shelter Island 27
👛 Lowest price 8731 INR
✍️ Hotels Reviews 633